Only What’s Necessary

New releases

The sensibility of Only What’s Necessary: Charles M. Schulz and the Art of Peanuts, the new book from designer Chip Kidd and photographer Geoff Spear, will seem very familiar to folks who bought Kidd’s earlier Peanuts: The Art of Charles M. Schulz. It displays Peanuts work not as it was meant to be reproduced, but either as it truly was – plenty of reproductions of original art here, including of unfinished materials – or as it was actually reproduced, as the book shows you pictures of printed comic book pages, the proof sheets sent to newspapers, product items, and so forth.

A lot of the material covered here you’ve likely not seen unless you’ve covered all the Schulz stuff obsessively, and some of it not even then. They show the art for four installments of the Mrs. Hagemeyer strip that Schulz once did samples for, some samples that Schulz did up for that strip that would become Peanuts, before they had set the panel count at 4,  There are reproductions of notecards based on Schulz’s “Young Pillars” strip, which I had heard of but even as the most recent reprinter of “Young Pillars”, I’d never actually seen them. (On the other hand, I got to say “hey, I put that in print before he did – those unfinished strips were on a story I published in Hogan’s Alley, the Glickman correspondence first saw print in another Hogan’s Alley article, and those ‘It’s Only a Game’ cartoons were first in book form in a book I published… shot from the same source, even!”)

The format of the book is a bit odd; it has cardboard covers, but unlike with a standard hardcover book, the edges of the pages go all the way to the cover. That means that the cover isn’t doing the normal amount of protecting the interior; ding the corner of the book and, as I’ve already found out, all the pages get dinged as well. And for those of us who might use this for research and discussion, the lack of page numbers is unhelpful.

Still, it’s a good book. I like having the Kidd books around as a different way of looking at Peanuts. It’s not the first Peanuts book that anyone should own; for that, you want a proper strip collection. But it’s a good part of the bookshelf for those who are serious about the work, and I look forward to spending more time poring over it (I had to give it a quick flip through and then get back to meeting some deadlines!)


Two lambs BAAAHH at Snoopy
New releases
Review: Scotland Bound, Charlie Brown

I managed to get my hands on a print copy of the new graphic novel Scotland Bound, Charlie Brown, which isn’t coming from Amazon for a couple weeks yet, simply by buying it at my local comic book store instead. (Support your comic shop, folks!) This is an adaptation of …

Greatest hits
Trivial invasion

What is the latest craze for unlicensed print-on-demand and Kindle Peanuts books? Let’s take a look! All eight of these trivia books came out in the past 5 weeks. And all of them are pretty clearly unlicensed. Not that they don’t take copyright seriously, mind you. Copyright is a very …

New releases
The other Peanuts

So it looks as though the same bozos who have been repeatedly publishing unlicensed Kindle collections of Peanuts works are also doing the same with Diary of a Wimpy Kid books… and labeling them as being Peanuts. (I’m not going to link in this case — my “hey, look at this!” …